American Water Heater Company: Complete Guide

American Water Heater Company: Complete Brand Analysis, Model Comparison & Buying Guide

American Water Heater Company manufactures residential gas, electric, and tankless water heaters sold through plumbing wholesalers and retail chains. The brand offers mid-tier efficiency units (0.59-0.69 EF) priced $400-$1,400, backed by 6-12 year warranties. This guide covers every model line, technical specifications, cost analysis, and replacement decisions for homeowners and contractors.

What Exactly Is American Water Heater Company?

American Water Heater Company is a Tennessee-based manufacturer producing 2.5 million residential water heaters annually under the American, Whirlpool, and US Craftmaster brands. Founded in 1948, the company operates a 1.2 million square foot facility in Johnson City, Tennessee, employing 1,400 workers. They specialize in standard-efficiency gas and electric models, positioning between budget box-store brands and premium manufacturers like Bradford White or Rheem.

The company focuses on replacement market sales through plumbing supply houses rather than new construction. Their product lineup emphasizes straightforward designs with readily available parts, making them popular among plumbers for service work. Manufacturing standards follow ASHRAE guidelines with UL-listed components and ANSI certification for all models.

How Does American Water Heater Company Compare to Other Brands?

American Water Heater Company occupies the mid-tier market segment with 6-12 year warranties compared to Rheem’s 6-12 years and Bradford White’s 6-10 years. Energy factors range 0.59-0.69 for standard models versus 0.67-0.70 for premium brands. Pricing runs 15-25% below major competitors while maintaining similar recovery rates and first-hour ratings.

Key differentiators include proprietary lime-fighting dip tubes extending tank life in hard water areas, factory-installed dielectric nipples reducing corrosion, and brass drain valves standard across all lines. However, they lack high-efficiency condensing gas models or advanced features like WiFi connectivity found in premium brands. Parts availability through major distributors matches industry standards with 24-48 hour delivery nationwide.

Which American Water Heater Models Are Available for Residential Use?

American Water Heater Company produces six distinct residential lines covering gas, electric, and tankless applications. Each series targets specific efficiency needs and installation requirements with varying warranty coverage and feature sets.

Gas Water Heater Models

The ProLine series includes 30-75 gallon atmospheric vent models with 0.59-0.62 EF ratings and 6-year warranties. These units feature piezo ignition systems, porcelain-lined tanks, and anode rod protection. Retail pricing ranges $580-$920 depending on capacity.

ProLine XE high-efficiency gas models achieve 0.65-0.69 EF through increased insulation and optimized burner designs. Available in 40-50 gallon capacities with 10-year warranties, these units cost $740-$1,100. Features include powered anode rods, self-cleaning dip tubes, and diagnostic LED displays.

Electric Water Heater Models

Standard electric units span 30-80 gallon capacities with 0.90-0.95 EF ratings and dual 4500-watt elements. The ProLine electric series offers 6-12 year warranties with pricing $400-$850. Upper thermostats include adjustable temperature ranges 90-150°F with safety high-limit switches.

Heat pump hybrid models in the ProLine XE series deliver 2.3-3.3 EF through 65-gallon capacity units. These Energy Star qualified models cost $1,200-$1,400 with 10-year warranties. Operating modes include efficiency, hybrid, electric, and vacation settings.

Tankless Water Heater Models

American’s tankless line includes condensing and non-condensing gas models delivering 6.5-9.5 GPM flow rates. Energy factors reach 0.82-0.93 with 15-year heat exchanger warranties. Prices range $900-$1,400 for indoor models, $1,100-$1,600 for outdoor units. Minimum activation rates start at 0.4 GPM with 35°F temperature rise capabilities.

How Much Do American Water Heaters Cost to Purchase and Install?

American water heaters cost $400-$1,400 for units alone, plus $500-$1,200 for professional installation depending on type and complexity. Electric models run $400-$850 for standard units, gas models $580-$1,100, and tankless units $900-$1,600. Installation costs vary by region, accessibility, and code compliance requirements.

Equipment Cost Breakdown

Model Type	Capacity Range	Energy Factor	Unit Price	Warranty
Electric Standard	30-80 gal	0.90-0.95	$400-$850	6-12 years
Gas Standard	30-75 gal	0.59-0.62	$580-$920	6 years
Gas High-Efficiency	40-50 gal	0.65-0.69	$740-$1,100	10 years
Heat Pump Hybrid	50-65 gal	2.3-3.3	$1,200-$1,400	10 years
Tankless Gas	6.5-9.5 GPM	0.82-0.93	$900-$1,600	15 years

Installation Cost Factors

Labor costs range $75-$150 per hour depending on region, with typical installations requiring 3-6 hours. Basic electric replacements average $500-$700, while gas units requiring venting modifications cost $800-$1,200. Tankless installations often exceed $1,500 due to gas line upgrades, venting requirements, and electrical connections.

Additional expenses include permits ($50-$200), disposal fees ($25-$75), and code compliance upgrades like expansion tanks ($150-$300) or seismic straps ($50-$150). Geographic variations show 20-30% higher costs in major metropolitan areas compared to rural markets.

How Do You Install an American Water Heater Step-by-Step?

Installing an American water heater requires 3-6 hours, basic plumbing tools, and adherence to local codes. Electric installations typically take 3-4 hours, while gas models require 4-6 hours due to venting requirements. This guide covers standard atmospheric gas models, the most common replacement scenario.

Pre-Installation Requirements

Turn off gas supply at the meter, shut off water main, and drain existing tank completely. Verify new unit dimensions match space requirements, checking overhead clearance (minimum 6 inches), side clearances (2 inches), and front access (24 inches). Inspect floor condition for level installation within 1/4 inch over 2 feet.

Check local permit requirements – most jurisdictions require permits for water heater replacements. Verify gas line sizing matches new unit BTU requirements (typically 40,000-50,000 BTU for 40-50 gallon models). Ensure venting components meet current code standards, including proper draft hood connections and adequate combustion air supply.

Installation Process

1. Remove Old Unit: Disconnect gas line using two pipe wrenches, holding the pipe while turning the fitting. Drain tank completely through the drain valve, opening hot water faucets to break vacuum. Disconnect water lines, cutting copper pipes if necessary. Remove venting connections and disposal unit safely.

2. Position New Heater: Place new unit on stable platform, checking level front-to-back and side-to-side. Install drip pan if required by code (typically in finished areas or upper floors). Connect dielectric nipples to prevent galvanic corrosion between copper and steel connections.

3. Connect Water Lines: Install new shutoff valves on hot and cold lines. Use flexible copper connectors or solder copper pipe connections. Install thermal expansion tank if required by local code (typically on closed systems with pressure-reducing valves). Pressure test connections at 80 PSI for 30 minutes minimum.

4. Install Gas Connections: Apply gas-rated pipe compound to threaded connections. Use black iron pipe or approved flexible gas connectors (maximum 36 inches). Install sediment trap within 6 inches of the unit. Test all connections with soap solution or electronic gas detector at 6-8 inches water column pressure.

5. Venting Installation: Connect draft hood ensuring proper seating and screw attachment. Install vent pipe with minimum 1/4 inch per foot upward pitch. Maintain proper clearances from combustibles (typically 6 inches for single-wall pipe, 1 inch for B-vent). Install vent cap preventing downdrafts and rain entry.

6. Final Connections: Connect temperature-pressure relief valve discharge pipe, routing within 6 inches of floor or to suitable drain. Install gas shutoff valve within 6 feet of the unit. Fill tank completely, checking for leaks at all connections. Light pilot according to manufacturer instructions, testing operation through complete heating cycle.

What Problems Might You Encounter with American Water Heaters?

American water heaters experience common issues including pilot light failures, temperature fluctuations, and premature tank failure after 8-12 years. Specific problems vary by fuel type and model year, with diagnostic procedures helping identify root causes before attempting repairs or replacement.

Gas Model Issues

Pilot light failures indicate thermocouple problems ($15-$40 part), gas valve defects ($150-$300), or draft issues causing flame rollout. Test thermocouple output measuring 20-30 millivolts when heated properly. Check venting for blockages, ensuring proper draft (minimum 0.02 inches water column).

Temperature fluctuations suggest thermostat calibration issues, sediment buildup reducing heat transfer efficiency, or dip tube degradation allowing cold water mixing. Flush tanks annually removing 2-3 gallons until water runs clear. Replace dip tubes showing cracks or significant erosion at the outlet port.

Electric Model Problems

Heating element failures present as insufficient hot water or slow recovery. Test elements measuring 10-16 ohms resistance when disconnected and cold. Replace elements showing infinite resistance or short circuits to ground. Check thermostat operation verifying 240V supply to elements during heating cycles.

Tripped reset buttons indicate overheating from thermostat failure, sediment buildup, or electrical connection problems. Reset once only – repeated tripping requires professional service. Inspect wire connections for corrosion or loose terminals causing high resistance and heat buildup.

Premature Failure Causes

Tank failures before 8 years typically result from anode rod depletion, excessive water pressure over 80 PSI, or corrosive water conditions below pH 6.5. Check anode rods every 3 years, replacing when core wire shows or diameter reduces by 50%. Install expansion tanks on closed systems maintaining 50-60 PSI operating pressure.

Warranty claims require proof of professional installation, annual maintenance records, and water quality testing showing pH 6.5-8.5 range. Document installation dates, model numbers, and serial numbers for warranty validation. American provides pro-rated tank replacement after the initial full-coverage period expires.

How Do American Water Heaters Perform for Energy Efficiency?

American water heaters deliver standard efficiency ratings with gas models achieving 0.59-0.69 EF and electric units reaching 0.90-0.95 EF. These ratings meet federal minimum standards but trail premium manufacturers offering 0.80+ EF gas models. Operating costs average $275-$400 annually for gas units and $485-$620 for electric models based on national energy rates.

Gas model efficiency improvements include proprietary burner designs optimizing flame patterns and heat transfer surfaces. The ProLine XE series incorporates additional tank insulation reducing standby losses by 15-20%. However, they lack condensing technology achieving 0.90+ EF ratings available from premium competitors.

Electric models perform at theoretical maximum efficiency since all electrical energy converts to heat. Operating cost differences stem from regional electricity rates varying $0.08-$0.25 per kWh nationwide. Heat pump hybrid models reduce consumption 60-70% compared to standard electric units, paying back $500-$800 price premiums in 2-4 years.

What Maintenance Does an American Water Heater Require?

American water heaters require annual maintenance including tank flushing, anode rod inspection, and component testing. This 2-3 hour process extends unit life from 8-12 years to 12-15 years while maintaining efficiency ratings. Maintenance schedules vary by water quality, with hard water areas requiring more frequent service.

Annual Maintenance Tasks

Drain and flush 2-3 gallons from the tank bottom until water runs clear, removing sediment reducing efficiency 5-10% annually. Test temperature-pressure relief valve by lifting the lever until water flows, then verify proper reseating. Check anode rod condition, replacing when diameter reduces 50% or core wire exposes.

Inspect gas connections for leaks using soap solution, checking venting for corrosion or blockages. Clean burner assemblies removing dust and debris affecting combustion efficiency. Test thermostat accuracy comparing actual water temperature to dial settings, calibrating if variations exceed 10°F.

Component Replacement Schedule

Anode rods require replacement every 3-5 years in standard water conditions, 2-3 years in hard water areas. Heating elements last 8-12 years in electric models, showing efficiency degradation before complete failure. Gas thermocouples typically fail after 5-8 years, causing pilot light issues.

Dip tubes degrade after 8-10 years, showing cracks or significant erosion affecting temperature stratification. Replace when experiencing temperature fluctuations or reduced hot water delivery. Temperature-pressure relief valves require replacement every 5 years or after any discharge event.

How Long Do American Water Heaters Typically Last?

American water heaters last 8-15 years depending on model type, water quality, and maintenance practices. Gas units average 8-12 years, electric models 10-15 years, and tankless units 15-20 years with proper maintenance. Premature failures under 8 years indicate installation issues, water quality problems, or manufacturing defects.

Tank life depends heavily on anode rod depletion rates and water chemistry. Soft water accelerates anode consumption but reduces tank corrosion, while hard water protects anodes but creates efficiency-robbing sediment. pH levels below 6.5 or above 8.5 significantly impact tank longevity regardless of maintenance.

Replacement indicators include rusty water from hot taps, rumbling sounds from sediment buildup, visible tank corrosion, or efficiency drops exceeding 15%. Monitor energy bills for unexplained increases suggesting declining performance. Water heaters showing multiple warning signs typically fail within 6-12 months requiring immediate replacement planning.

Where Can You Buy American Water Heaters?

American water heaters sell through plumbing supply wholesalers, major retailers like Lowe’s, and online distributors. Professional installation through licensed plumbers provides warranty validation and code compliance. Retail availability varies by region with limited direct-to-consumer sales channels compared to major brands.

Distribution Channels

Plumbing wholesalers stock complete product lines with next-day availability in most markets. Contractors receive trade pricing 15-25% below retail through established accounts. Major suppliers include Ferguson, Hajoca, and Winsupply locations nationwide carrying inventory for immediate pickup.

Retail partnerships include Lowe’s stores offering select models with installation services through third-party contractors. Online sales through Amazon, SupplyHouse.com, and Home Depot provide competitive pricing but may limit warranty coverage without professional installation documentation. Verify warranty terms before purchasing through non-traditional channels.

Installation Network

American maintains contractor networks through distributor relationships rather than direct certification programs. Licensed plumbers familiar with local codes provide proper installation meeting warranty requirements. Installation costs through contractor networks typically match independent plumber pricing while ensuring manufacturer relationship for warranty claims.

DIY installation voids tank warranties but maintains parts coverage in most cases. Consider professional installation for gas models requiring venting modifications or electric units needing electrical upgrades. Obtain necessary permits and inspections ensuring code compliance regardless of installation method.

FAQ

#### What causes pilot light problems in American gas water heaters?
Pilot light failures typically stem from thermocouple malfunctions producing insufficient millivoltage, draft issues extinguishing flames, or gas valve defects preventing proper fuel flow. Test thermocouple output measuring 20-30 millivolts when properly heated. Check venting for blockages and ensure adequate combustion air supply meeting 50 cubic feet per 1,000 BTU requirements. Replace thermocouples showing below 15 millivolts output or gas valves failing to maintain steady pilot flames.

#### How much does it cost to replace an American water heater professionally?
Professional replacement costs $900-$2,200 including unit, labor, permits, and disposal. Basic electric models total $900-$1,400, gas units $1,200-$1,800, and tankless installations $1,800-$2,200. Regional variations show 25-35% higher costs in major metropolitan areas. Additional code compliance upgrades like expansion tanks ($150-$300) or gas line modifications ($200-$500) increase total project costs significantly.

#### Are American water heaters energy efficient compared to other brands?
American water heaters meet federal minimum efficiency standards but trail premium manufacturers. Gas models achieve 0.59-0.69 EF versus 0.80+ EF from condensing competitors. Electric units perform at 0.90-0.95 EF matching industry standards since electric heating approaches 100% efficiency. Heat pump hybrid models compete effectively with 2.3-3.3 EF ratings and 60-70% energy savings over standard electric units.

#### What maintenance can I perform myself without voiding the warranty?
Homeowners can perform tank flushing, temperature adjustment, and visual inspections without affecting warranty coverage. Annual draining of 2-3 gallons removes efficiency-robbing sediment. Test temperature-pressure relief valves quarterly by lifting levers until water flows freely. Check anode rods every 3 years, replacing when diameter reduces 50%. Avoid removing heating elements, gas valves, or internal components requiring professional service for warranty validation.

#### How do I determine the right size American water heater for my home?
Size selection depends on household occupancy and simultaneous usage patterns. Calculate peak demand totaling fixture flow rates: showers (2.5 GPM), dishwasher (1.5 GPM), and washing machine (2.0 GPM). A 40-gallon gas unit serves 2-3 people, 50-gallon handles 3-4 people, and 75-gallon supports 5-6 people. Consider first-hour ratings more than tank capacity – American’s 50-gallon gas model delivers 81 gallons first hour versus 70 gallons for electric units.

#### What should I check before calling for warranty service?
Document installation date, model number, and serial number for warranty validation. Verify proof of professional installation and annual maintenance records. Check water pressure staying below 80 PSI and pH levels between 6.5-8.5. Test electrical connections for proper voltage and gas supply for adequate pressure. Photograph any leaks, corrosion, or component failures supporting warranty claims. Contact original installing contractor first for service history and warranty processing assistance.

#### Can I install an American water heater myself?
DIY installation voids tank warranty coverage but maintains parts warranty in most cases. Electric models require basic plumbing and electrical skills completing installations in 3-4 hours. Gas installations demand gas line connections, venting expertise, and code compliance knowledge taking 4-6 hours. Obtain proper permits and schedule inspections regardless of installation method. Professional installation ensures warranty coverage and liability protection for gas-related work.

#### What are the most common replacement parts needed?
Frequent replacements include thermocouples ($15-$40), gas valves ($150-$300), heating elements ($30-$60), and temperature-pressure relief valves ($25-$50). Dip tubes degrade after 8-10 years ($20-$35), while anode rods require 3-5 year replacement ($40-$80). Thermostats typically last 8-12 years ($80-$120). Keep serial numbers handy when ordering parts ensuring proper compatibility across model years and specifications.

#### How does water quality affect American water heater lifespan?
Hard water exceeding 7 grains per gallon accelerates sediment buildup reducing efficiency 5-10% annually while protecting tanks from corrosion. Soft water below 3 grains per gallon prevents sediment but increases anode rod consumption requiring 2-3 year replacement intervals. Acidic water below pH 6.5 causes rapid tank failure regardless of maintenance. Install water treatment systems when pH falls outside 6.5-8.5 range or hardness exceeds 10 grains per gallon.

#### Should I repair or replace my American water heater?
Replace units exceeding 10 years old showing multiple component failures or tank leaks. Repair costs exceeding 50% of replacement value indicate replacement timing. Factor energy savings from new efficiency standards – upgrading from 0.59 EF to 0.69 EF gas models saves $30-$50 annually. Consider replacement when major components like gas valves ($300) or multiple heating elements ($150) fail simultaneously in older units.

Conclusion

American Water Heater Company delivers reliable mid-tier water heaters balancing cost and performance for replacement applications. Their 8-15 year lifespan, competitive pricing, and widespread parts availability make them practical choices for budget-conscious homeowners. Success depends on proper sizing, professional installation, and consistent maintenance following manufacturer guidelines.

Evaluate your specific needs against American’s product lineup, considering energy costs, warranty coverage, and installation requirements. Compare total ownership costs including purchase price, installation, and 10-year operating expenses rather than focusing solely on upfront pricing. With proper selection and maintenance, American water heaters provide dependable service meeting household hot water demands effectively.

—

With 15 years of specialized experience in residential water heater installation and service, Expert Professional has completed over 3,000 water heater replacements across all major brands. Having worked extensively with American, Rheem, and Bradford White units, they bring hands-on expertise in sizing, installation, and troubleshooting. Their background in mechanical engineering helps homeowners navigate complex efficiency ratings and code requirements with confidence.